Editorial Guide

Best Seafood Restaurants in Bluffton & Hilton Head Island

The Lowcountry is one of the great seafood regions in America. Here's where to eat it well — from shucked-to-order oysters in Old Town Bluffton to dockside platters on Hilton Head Island.

Updated October 2026

Bluffton and Hilton Head Island sit at the edge of the May River and the Atlantic, which means the seafood here isn't just fresh — it's local. The shrimp were likely caught that morning. The oysters may have been harvested from a creek you can see from your table.

This guide covers the restaurants our editors return to again and again: places where the sourcing is honest, the preparation respects the ingredient, and the setting makes the meal. We've organized it by what you're looking for, starting with Bluffton.

Best for Oysters — Bluffton

Bluffton Oyster Company

Editor's Top Pick

Old Town Bluffton

The most authentic oyster experience in the Lowcountry. Bluffton Oyster Company is a working seafood market and casual eatery on the May River — you can watch the boats come in. Order the local cluster oysters steamed or raw, the shrimp by the pound, and whatever the daily catch is. No frills, no pretense, and no better place to understand why Bluffton's seafood reputation is what it is.

Must order: Local cluster oysters, steamed shrimp

Best for: Casual lunch, local experience, families

Captain Woody's

Local Favorite

Old Town Bluffton

A relaxed, waterfront-adjacent spot that locals have been going to for years. The oysters are reliably good, the atmosphere is casual and friendly, and the patio is one of the better places to spend a Bluffton afternoon. Order the oyster po'boy if it's on the menu.

Must order: Oysters, po'boys, steamed shrimp

Best for: Casual dining, outdoor seating, groups

Best for a Seafood Dinner — Bluffton

May River Grill

Best All-Around

Bluffton

May River Grill has been a Bluffton institution for good reason: consistent quality, a menu that leans into local seafood without being gimmicky, and a room that works for both a casual weeknight and a proper dinner out. The she-crab soup is among the best in the area. The grilled fish changes with the season — always order it.

Must order: She-crab soup, grilled local fish, shrimp and grits

Best for: Dinner, date night, special occasions

Nectar Farm Kitchen

Farm-to-Coast

Bluffton Road

Nectar Farm Kitchen takes a farm-to-table approach to Lowcountry seafood — sourcing locally, cooking seasonally, and presenting it all in a warm, unpretentious room. The menu changes frequently, which is a feature, not a bug. If local shrimp or flounder is on the menu, order it.

Must order: Seasonal local fish, shrimp dishes, vegetable sides

Best for: Dinner, farm-to-table enthusiasts, date night

Best Waterfront Seafood — Hilton Head Island

Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks

Classic HHI Institution

Hilton Head Island

Hudson's has been on the docks since 1967, and it earns its reputation every service. The setting — boats in the water, pelicans overhead, sunset over the sound — is unmatched. The seafood is straightforward and excellent: fried shrimp, steamed crab, fresh fish. Go early; the wait can be long and there's no reservations.

Must order: Fried shrimp, steamed crab, fresh catch

Best for: Sunset dining, families, classic HHI experience

Skull Creek Boathouse

Best Views

Hilton Head Island

A large, lively waterfront restaurant with some of the best sunset views on the island. The menu is broad — sushi, seafood, burgers — but the local seafood dishes are the reason to go. The outdoor deck fills up fast; arrive before 6pm if you want a waterfront table.

Must order: Local fish, oysters, sunset cocktails on the deck

Best for: Groups, sunset dining, lively atmosphere

Old Oyster Factory

Scenic & Reliable

Hilton Head Island

Built on the site of a historic oyster cannery, the Old Oyster Factory offers marsh views, reliable seafood, and a menu that covers all the Lowcountry classics. It's a dependable choice for visitors and a solid option when you want a proper seafood dinner without surprises.

Must order: Oysters, she-crab soup, grilled fish

Best for: Visitors, scenic dining, reliable quality

Lowcountry Seafood: What to Know

→

Bluffton oysters are cluster oysters — smaller and brinier than Gulf oysters. They're best steamed or raw with minimal accompaniment.

→

White shrimp season runs roughly May through December. If you're visiting in that window, order the local shrimp over imported.

→

She-crab soup is a Lowcountry staple — a rich, cream-based bisque made with blue crab and crab roe. It varies significantly by restaurant; the best versions are worth seeking out.

→

Many of the best seafood spots don't take reservations. Arrive early, especially on weekends and in peak season (March–May, October–November).

Browse All Seafood Restaurants

See the full directory of seafood restaurants in Bluffton and Hilton Head Island.

View seafood listings →More editorial guides →